While Manning had inconsistent regular-season play, his Hall of Fame merits reside in his clutch postseason performances, as he led two of the greatest runs to Super Bowl titles in league history. Whether he finishes a few games over .500 or a few games under hardly matters to me at this point. New York Giants quarterback Eli Manning beat the New England Patriots in the Super Bowl twice, both with fourth-quarter game-winning drives. A Hall of Fame class cannot include more than five modern-era inductees. Philip Rivers will get consideration for the Hall, same passer rating as Joe Flacco, and they were contemporaries. Community Rules apply to all content you upload or otherwise submit to this site. The last time Manning started a game with a .500 career record was Sept. 30, 2007, when he was 21-21. After both Super Bowls, he was selected as MVP. The numbers are there. That certainly helps his cause. ", Anonymous voter 8: “In his last seven years, he has been one of the lowest-performing starters in the NFL, among quarterbacks who have played those seven seasons. Think about it from the perspective of a football fan 30 to 40 years from now, looking back over the history of the league and seeing there was a quarterback who didn't miss a game due to injury for a 15-year stretch and during that stretch won the Super Bowl twice, both times against Tom Brady's Patriots, once when those Patriots came into the game 18-0. Manning had a good career in New York, but the Hall of Fame is reserved for the best quarterbacks of all time -- he simply doesn't stack up. Either way, Manning is a Hall of Fame outlier. I’ve watched Eli for 15 years and not once have I thought, ‘I’m watching a Hall of Famer who leads teams.’ But, if I had to bet, Eli is going to make it — not because of how he played but where he played. So does the New York market. Who cares if it's not on roller skates? Eli should not be judged on the recent seasons but on his total career, highlighted by two Super Bowls in which he outperformed Tom Brady.”, Jason Cole, FanSided: “Eli played a lot of his career as if he rolled out of bed on Saturday morning from the frat house after a serious mega-kegger the night before. But ultimately his postseason success might be too hard to ignore.”, Dan Fouts, CBS and Hall of Fame quarterback: “I try to stay away (from commenting) unless it’s obvious. The Hall of Fame tells the story of the game's history, and Manning is an essential part of that history as it pertains to his era. Ian O'Connor, senior writer: Yes. Or are the Giants trying to save a 38-year-old fierce competitor — who has given no indication he wants to retire soon — from himself? He was obviously talented, had a lot of fun, and sometimes it was great and sometimes it wasn’t. NJ Advance Media spoke to 39 of 48 members on the Hall of Fame’s selection committee (comprised of NFL media, including two inductees) and 30 agreed to participate in a two-question survey, while others spoke in general terms: “I think he has hurt his Hall of Fame resume by staying around as long as he has,” one voter replied. Buy Eli Manning Giants gear: Fanatics, NFLShop, Lids, Champs Sports, Dick's Sporting Goods. Ryan Dunleavy may be reached at [email protected]. Dan Graziano, national NFL writer: Yes, of course. Well, Manning has been available his entire career. Matt Bowen, NFL writer: Yes. But those Super Bowl teams won more because of defense than offense. given no indication he wants to retire soon. I don't think so. Field Yates, NFL analyst: Yes. Max Kellerman argues that the Giants' benching of Eli Manning for Daniel Jones is premature this early in the season. ET and will air on NJTV and WWOR/MY9, as well as the New Jersey Hall of Fame Facebook page and YouTube channel. Something has to give. The former New York Giants quarterback was inducted into the New Jersey Hall of Fame during Sunday’s virtual ceremony. 26 in the league since 2006. It doesn't mean I am, or am not, putting Manning on the list, but it does mean the most important part of the process is that each player's circumstances and output deserve to be considered in context. The Giants closed the book on Eli Manning’s days as a starting quarterback and opened the great debate on his career: Has he done enough to get into the Pro Football Hall of Fame? Fans with a … https://giantswire.usatoday.com/2020/10/18/new-york-giants-eli-manning-new-jersey-hall-fame-induction-airs-sunday/, Clio Sports to honor Giants legend Eli Manning with specialty award, Eli Manning partners with Yahoo! We're talking 12 guys. He is Hall of Famer.”, Scott Garceau, 105.7 The Fan in Baltimore: “His numbers (top eight all-time in yards and touchdowns), postseason success and so-over looked availability (210 consecutive starts). He was twice the best player in the NFL at his position during Super Bowl runs. Is he one of those players? By then, it’ll be easier to see the totality of a Hall of Fame career versus a declining 38 year old. Or he will join Jim Plunkett as the only omitted quarterbacks with multiple Super Bowl wins. But Manning also joins Jim Plunkett, Doug Williams and Joe Namath as the only Super Bowl champion quarterbacks without a winning record as a starting QB (116-116). Your grandchildren are finding out about this player and asking you, "How come this guy isn't in the Hall of Fame?" You get credit for the wins and you get blamed for the losses.”, Darin Gantt, Pro Football Talk: “It’s not Eli’s fault that Jerry Reese wasn’t a good steward of free-agent money, or that someone gave him the regrettable Ben McAdoo, or that Dave Gettleman ran a double-reverse with Odell Beckham Jr., or that Ereck Flowers wasn’t very good at football. NFL experts cast their votes, 49ers lose Samuel, Wilson for multiple weeks, Cowboys DC feels heat after hot sauce mishap, Source: Cards RB Drake likely out a few weeks, Seahawks' Carson week-to-week with foot sprain, Gase backs Darnold after QB's clunker vs. Bills, McCaffrey returns to practice field; status still iffy, 'Embarrassed' Cam admits job may be in jeopardy. © 2020 Advance Local Media LLC. ", Anonymous voter 11: “He falls short of slam-dunk in my opinion, but he’s certainly in the ballpark for further thought and discussion being the quarterback who not only won two Super Bowls but took down the Patriots both times.”, Anonymous voter 12: “What bothers me about Eli is what looks to be an all-or-nothing aspect to his career. The 2004 first overall draft pick also went one-and-done in the playoffs four times and missed them entirely nine times. SL, (This story was originally published in September 2019.). The Bucs opened as 10-point favorites over the home Giants with the over/under launching at 47.5 points, per BetMGM. But the clincher is that he’s never been an All-Pro. So, how can he not be immortalized along with the elite company he shares? Note to readers: if you purchase something through one of our affiliate links we may earn a commission. Manning has the top-flight passing numbers and the magnificent durability to cement his legacy of greatness. We’re here when you need us most. Yeah, he’s a good quarterback and won two Super Bowls.

Portsmouth Bus Schedule, Hannah Messier Wctv, Celtic Rumours, Problem Statement For Education Industry, Shauna Lake, Lyndon B Johnson Death, Ell/mll Accommodations, Columbus Crew Academy Cost,